Breaking Rust, AI Cowboys and the Lie Behind the Charts

An AI cowboy called Breaking Rust just hit number one on a Billboard country chart with the song “Walk My Walk.” Millions of streams. A fake artist. No singer. No band. Just code, prompts and a marketing plan.

You’ve probably seen the headlines: “AI country singer tops the charts”, “AI slop is number one on Billboard”. Some people are hyped. Most musicians are furious. Even Rick Beato – one of the few big YouTube voices who still talks honestly about music – pointed out how absurd it is that this AI project has millions of monthly listeners and a number-one country digital single with only a few thousand paid downloads behind it.

So let’s cut through the noise. This isn’t just about AI. This is about how fake the game has always been – and why this stunt hurts so much if you’re a real musician.

What actually happened with Breaking Rust?

Quick facts, minus the drama:

Breaking Rust is an AI-generated country “artist” – no human singer, no band.
The song “Walk My Walk” hit #1 on Billboard’s Country Digital Song Sales chart, not on the overall airplay or streaming chart.
It racked up millions of streams on Spotify in a short time and climbed viral playlists while the story exploded in the media.
That digital sales chart is easy to game: very few people buy downloads anymore, so a few thousand purchases can push a song to #1. Critics have been warning for years that this specific chart is a playground for manipulation.

So yes, technically, “Walk My Walk” is a Billboard #1 – but on a niche digital-sales chart that doesn’t reflect what most people actually listen to daily. Still, Billboard put it there. The headlines did the rest.

Why everyone is freaking out

Reactions fall in a few predictable categories:

“The song sucks.”
People attack the lyrics, the generic arrangement, the fake cowboy image, the Instagram AI videos.
“This is AI slop.”
Critics call it generic, soulless content built to farm streams and outrage clicks, not to express anything real.
“You can buy a number one now.”
Commentators talk openly about how a few thousand paid downloads – maybe around the cost of a mid-level promo budget – can manufacture a “#1” story and free PR.
“This steals attention and money from real artists.”
If charts, playlists and press are busy with synthetic “artists”, what’s left for actual bands and songwriters?

Reality check: this didn’t start with AI

Here’s the uncomfortable truth:

Labels and managers have been buying their way into charts since the 70s.
Different methods, same game:

radio payola and backroom deals
manufactured single sales and “fan club” bulk buys
playlist manipulation
fake hype campaigns built only to trigger headlines
labels buying their own albums and singles

The only thing that changed now is the center of the scam.

Before: it was a human face fronting a heavily manufactured product.
Now: it’s a fully synthetic persona – cowboy hat, gravel-voice, AI-written lyrics and all – built to hit emotional keywords and algorithm triggers.

The mechanism is identical: take a weak song, prop it up with money, spin, charts and conflict… and watch the clicks roll in.

So what’s everyone really angry about?

Let’s be brutally honest for a second.

Most musicians aren’t just mad that Breaking Rust is fake.
They’re mad that:

An AI project proved how replaceable the “product” can be.
If generic lyrics + generic melody + generic fake singer are enough for millions of streams and a Billboard headline… what does that say about all the safe, copy-paste music humans have been making?
The industry admitted what it really values.
Not authenticity.
Not musicianship.
Not years of grinding on the road.
But cheap content that goes viral fast and can be monetised immediately.
The mask slipped.
For decades, people still wanted to believe:
“If I work hard, write good songs and become great at my instrument, the industry will eventually notice.”
Then a non-existent cowboy walks in, hits #1 on a Billboard chart with no band, no touring, no blood, no sweat – and gets global coverage.

Of course that feels like a slap in the face.

Are you angry at AI – or at the mirror?

AI didn’t invent:

laziness
copying trends
buying exposure
faking credibility with numbers

Humans did.

What AI did is accelerate and expose a process that was already there:

It shows how much of the industry is fine with music being a mass-produced content feed.
It shows how fragile the myth of “real artist development” has become.
It shows how many listeners don’t care who made the song, as long as it fits a mood playlist at the gym or in the car.

That’s why this hurts.
Not because one AI cowboy hit #1 on a niche chart…
…but because deep down, a lot of musicians feel the question:

“If the industry is happy with AI slop… what exactly do they need me for?”

What you should do if you’re a real musician

You can’t out-algorithm AI.
You’ll never be faster, cheaper or more flexible than a bot.

So stop trying.

Instead, double down on what AI can’t steal:

Real stories and scars
Breaking Rust has no childhood, no heartbreak, no bad tour memories, no near-breakups, no actual life. You do. Use that.
Live performance and connection
An AI cowboy can’t stand in front of 50 people in a bar, look them in the eyes and make them shut up and listen.
Imperfection
All the things that make you not “perfect” – your accent, your phrasing, your weird influences, your struggles – are exactly what makes you irreplaceable.
Community
An algorithm can generate fans. A human can build relationships.

The real question

The music industry will absolutely exploit AI.
There will be more fake artists, fake chart stunts, fake hype cycles.

You can waste your energy screaming at the machine…
or you can ask yourself a harder question:

Are you really angry at AI — or terrified it just proved how generic most of the industry already is?

If you refuse to be generic, you already know what to do next:
write better songs, tell truer stories, and build something that a cowboy made of code can’t touch.

Transcript

An AI cowboy called Breaking Rust just hit number one on a Billboard country chart with Walk My Walk. Millions of streams. A fake artist.
Rick Beato is actually one of the most honest voices describing the industry’s panic.

Rick Beato: “It’s ridiculous that it has 2.28 million monthly listeners.”

Others say the song sucks, the lyrics are trash, the voice is fake, and it’s a scandal that you can just buy your way into the charts.

Rick Beato: “So it cost $3,000 to make a number one.”

Reality check: labels have been buying their way into the charts since the 70s.
That didn’t start with AI.
Fake hype, fake spins, fake number-one spots.
That’s the music business on a Tuesday.

The only difference now?
It’s not a human at the center of the scam.
It’s code.

So be honest.
Are you really angry at AI — or terrified it just proved you are replaceable?

Take Your Guitar Playing To The Next Level!

If you like clear, practical guitar and music coaching instead of random YouTube tips, you need structure. My guitar books and coaching programs give you that structure, so you can finally make real progress and level up your playing.