How Many Riffs Does a Great Song Really Need?

Musicians obsess over riffs — guitar riffs, piano riffs, vocal hooks, chord stabs, rhythmic patterns.
But here’s a truth almost nobody wants to hear:

The greatest songs in the world are rarely built from more than one strong idea.

As a producer, I see this all the time.
An artist walks into the studio with six or seven riffs, convinced every idea is essential.

But the reality?

I’ll throw away six of them.
And rebuild the entire track around the one idea that actually works.

That’s not disrespect.
That’s songwriting.

The best songs aren’t “collections” of ideas —
they’re focused expressions of one unforgettable idea.

Think of the classics:

One riff
One hook
One emotional center
One identity

That’s all it takes.

Why Extra Riffs Kill Great Songs

When a song has too many riffs, two things happen:

The listener gets confused — the brain can’t latch onto anything.
The identity disappears — if everything stands out, nothing stands out.

Great songs are memorable because they’re simple, recognizable and focused.

That’s why producers cut aggressively.
Not to destroy ideas —
but to protect the one idea worth keeping.

What About the Other Six Riffs?

Here’s the good news most musicians overlook:

Nothing is wasted.

If you bring me seven riffs and I keep only one,
that doesn’t mean the other six are trash.

It means:

You just wrote the foundations for six new songs.

One becomes a new chorus
Another becomes a completely different track
Another becomes a verse hook
Another becomes a B-section for something else

Great writers don’t collect ideas.
They repurpose ideas.

This is how professionals think:
Nothing is ever “wrong.”
It’s just not right for this song.

The Real Lesson

If you want to grow as a songwriter, stop trying to fit everything into one track.

Ask yourself:

What’s the one idea that defines this song?
What can I remove without losing impact?
Which riffs belong to another song entirely?

Master the art of subtraction.
It’s one of the most powerful skills in music.

And the next time you feel discouraged because you “only finished one song,”
remember this:

Every unused riff is the beginning of another one.

You’re not running out of ideas.
You’re multiplying them.

Transcript

Music, songwriting and production tips.

How many guitar or piano riffs does a great song really need?

As a producer, sometimes an artist gives me seven riffs.
Chances are I’ll throw away six and rebuild the song from scratch.

The greatest hits and the best songs in the world are built around just one idea.

So what should you do with the six remaining riffs?
Well, that’s the good news:

You can write six new songs.

Take Your Guitar Playing To The Next Level!

If you like clear, practical guitar and music coaching instead of random YouTube tips, you need structure. My guitar books and coaching programs give you that structure, so you can finally make real progress and level up your playing.